Arbeitspapier

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

to related objects

This paper assesses the widely held belief that damages for pain and suffering are random or arbitrary. We empirically analyze the differential impact of a plaintiff's personal characteristics, pain-specific circumstances and a lawsuit's procedural features on such payments. Relying on a dataset of about 2,200 pain and suffering verdicts from Germany between 1980 and 2006, we observe that final awards are systematically influenced by the injury's conditions (most importantly the intensity and severity of damage), while individual characteristics such as gender and age turn out insignificant. Regarding the lawsuit, it appears to be relevant at which court level the case is brought in and whether the plaintiff hires a lawyer or not. On balance, our findings suggest that compensations are consistent with the legal framework of the German tort law, letting us conclude that damages for pain and suffering are widely predictable rather than random.

Language: Englisch

Bibliographic citation: Series: Working Papers in Economics and Finance ; No. 2015-02

Classification: Wirtschaft
Tort Law and Product Liability; Forensic Economics
Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior: General
Litigation Process

Subject: tort law
damages for pain and suffering
civil procedure

Event: Geistige Schöpfung

(who): Flatscher-Thöni, Magdalena
Leiter, Andrea M.
Winner, Hannes

Event: Veröffentlichung

(who): University of Salzburg, Department of Social Sciences and Economics

(where): Salzburg

(when): 2015

Handle: http://hdl.handle.net/10419/122168

Last update: 10.03.2025, 11:42 AM CET

Data provider

This object is provided by:
ZBW - Deutsche Zentralbibliothek für Wirtschaftswissenschaften - Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft. If you have any questions about the object, please contact the data provider.

Show original at data provider

Object type

Arbeitspapier

Associated

Flatscher-Thöni, Magdalena
Leiter, Andrea M.
Winner, Hannes
University of Salzburg, Department of Social Sciences and Economics

Time of origin

2015

Other Objects (12)

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

Artikel

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

Artikel

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

Artikel

Are pain and suffering awards (un-)predictable? Evidence from Germany

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

How predictable are the Academy Awards?

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Human Time Perception - Predictable visual stimuli are perceived earlier than unpredictable events

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Attention mechanisms during predictable and unpredictable threat - a steady-state visual evoked potential approach

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Conceptualizing suffering and pain

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Insula response to unpredictable and predictable aversiveness in individuals with panic disorder and comorbid depression

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Pathogen Safety of Long-Term Treatments for Bleeding Disorders: (Un)Predictable Risks and Evolving Threats

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Spatiotemporal modulation of a common set of muscle synergies during unpredictable and predictable gait perturbations in older adults

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Pupillometric parameters of alertness during unpredictable but not predictable smooth pursuit neck torsion test are altered in patients with neck pain disorders: a cross-sectional study

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

Unpredictable pain timings lead to greater pain when people are highly intolerant of uncertainty

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

The telos and ethos of pain and suffering

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Sleep quality in subjects suffering from chronic pain

Cultural heritage institutions wishing to register will find more information here.

Fields marked * need to be filled in.

Username*

Please enter your username

Email*

Please enter your email address

Please do not fill this field

First name

Last name

Password*

Please enter your password

Confirm password*

Please enter the same password

I have read the terms of use and the privacy policy for the collection of personal data and accept them. *

This field is required.

I would like to subscribe to the newsletter of the Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek. See newsletter subscription info.

Account created

Your "My DDB" account has been successfully created. Before you can log in to your account, you must click the confirmation link in the message we just sent to the email address you provided.