Making Secular Sense of the Sacred
Abstract: From the earliest days of social science, in the writings of David Hume and Adam Smith, it has been difficult to make secular sense of the notion of sacredness in terms that believers in that notion can recognize as what they mean by it-social scientists instead tend almost universally to treat it as the consequence of an illusion of some kind. This paper explores the sources of that difficulty, arguing that it is built into the assumptions that make social science a science at all. It also argues that treating a category so central to the moral thinking of millions of people as resulting from an illusion breeds attitudes of condescension that are morally problematic. Using themes to be found especially in Kant, the paper proposes a way for social scientists to treat the category of sacredness with respect for moral purposes even while maintaining the presuppositions, for the purposes of their scientific work, that lead them to try to explain it away.
- Location
-
Deutsche Nationalbibliothek Frankfurt am Main
- Extent
-
Online-Ressource
- Language
-
Englisch
- Bibliographic citation
-
Making Secular Sense of the Sacred ; volume:39 ; number:1 ; year:2017 ; pages:25-40 ; extent:16
Analyse & Kritik ; 39, Heft 1 (2017), 25-40 (gesamt 16)
- Creator
-
Fleischacker, Sam
- DOI
-
10.1515/auk-2017-0002
- URN
-
urn:nbn:de:101:1-2023120713185594610160
- Rights
-
Open Access; Der Zugriff auf das Objekt ist unbeschränkt möglich.
- Last update
-
15.08.2025, 7:22 AM CEST
Data provider
Deutsche Nationalbibliothek. If you have any questions about the object, please contact the data provider.
Associated
- Fleischacker, Sam
Other Objects (12)
Sacred Values in Secular Politics
Voices from altarpieces: Making sense of the sacred
Of the sacred and the secular: Missionary collections in university museums
Ethics and the Sacred: Can Secular Morality Dispense with Religious Values?
Dub in the Front Room: Migrant Aesthetics of the Sacred and the Secular
Howard Becker, Current Sacred-Secular Theory and its Development (Typoskript)
The seventeenth-century English hymn : a mode for sacred and secular concerns
Genealogies of the secular : the making of modern German thought
Calligraphie islamique : textes sacrés et profanes = Islamic calligraphy : sacred and secular writings
Secular, scarred and sacred : education and religion among the Black Community in Nineteenth-Century Canada
Religion, rationality and community : sacred and secular in the thought of Hegel and his critics
Secular and sacred? : the Scandinavian case of religion in human rights, law and public space
Sacred Values in Secular Politics
Voices from altarpieces: Making sense of the sacred
Of the sacred and the secular: Missionary collections in university museums
Ethics and the Sacred: Can Secular Morality Dispense with Religious Values?
Dub in the Front Room: Migrant Aesthetics of the Sacred and the Secular
Howard Becker, Current Sacred-Secular Theory and its Development (Typoskript)
The seventeenth-century English hymn : a mode for sacred and secular concerns
Genealogies of the secular : the making of modern German thought
Calligraphie islamique : textes sacrés et profanes = Islamic calligraphy : sacred and secular writings
Secular, scarred and sacred : education and religion among the Black Community in Nineteenth-Century Canada
Religion, rationality and community : sacred and secular in the thought of Hegel and his critics
Secular and sacred? : the Scandinavian case of religion in human rights, law and public space
Sacred Values in Secular Politics
Voices from altarpieces: Making sense of the sacred
Of the sacred and the secular: Missionary collections in university museums
Ethics and the Sacred: Can Secular Morality Dispense with Religious Values?
Dub in the Front Room: Migrant Aesthetics of the Sacred and the Secular
Howard Becker, Current Sacred-Secular Theory and its Development (Typoskript)
The seventeenth-century English hymn : a mode for sacred and secular concerns
Genealogies of the secular : the making of modern German thought
Calligraphie islamique : textes sacrés et profanes = Islamic calligraphy : sacred and secular writings
Secular, scarred and sacred : education and religion among the Black Community in Nineteenth-Century Canada
Religion, rationality and community : sacred and secular in the thought of Hegel and his critics